Our girl Angie Miller has made it to the top 8 but last night performance did not pose as her best.

She put a slight rock sponge on the Smokey Robinson and the Miracles classic "Shop Around," and the performance did not win unanimous races form the judges.

"It's the first time ever that I've seen you have a such a pithy performance," said Randy Jackson.

Mariah Carey called Miller's attempt to show a sassier side a little too risky and said she would have preferred to see the teen singing at the piano like she has done in the past.

Keith Urban thought Miller's tendency to go sharp was because of a difference between her energy levels and melody and the energy level of the song itself. 

As for Nicki Minaj, she told Miller that it was not necessary for her to show a different side and she should stick with what she's good at doing. 

Oh well Angie we have all the faith in the world for you! No worries, you'll get em next week!

Check out her Wednesday night performance to "Shop Around"